Olsman MacKenzie Peacock: Reviews for Medical Malpractice Lawyers in Michigan
A medical error changes everything. Whether the harm stems from a missed diagnosis, a surgical mistake, a preventable medication error, or a failure to act on warning signs, the consequences for patients and their families can be permanent and devastating. When that happens, many people turn to a Michigan medical malpractice attorney to hold the responsible medical providers accountable.
Finding the right attorney for a medical malpractice case is not a simple task. These cases require a law firm with the clinical knowledge to understand what went wrong medically, the investigative resources to build a case against well-funded hospital defense teams, and the courtroom experience to take that case to trial if necessary.
This page presents real reviews from clients and families who retained Olsman MacKenzie Peacock (OMP) after being harmed by medical negligence in Michigan. It also provides context on what those reviews mean, what to look for when evaluating a malpractice firm, and what we have recovered for our clients who have been injured due to medical malpractice.
OMP has been named as a U.S. News First-Tier ranked in Medical Malpractice Law for Plaintiffs. We handle all medical malpractice cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning no attorney fees are owed unless and until a recovery is obtained. We also offer a free, confidential consultation so that you can learn about your legal rights and options.
Call Us for a FREE Consultation No Fee Unless We Recover for You
What Do Clients Say About Olsman MacKenzie Peacock After a Medical Malpractice Case?
The following reviews were submitted by individuals and families who retained OMP to represent them in Michigan medical malpractice cases, including wrongful death, surgical error, medication mistakes, and failure to diagnose. Each reflects a firsthand account of the legal process.
A. | Google 5-Star Review
“Donna MacKenzie and the staff at Olsman MacKenzie Peacock were stellar in their communication, in answering questions and providing updates. My experience with them exceeded expectations, and they continued to reveal their professionalism, integrity, and fortitude. Not only is Donna MacKenzie a “powerhouse” in all ways, she was also approachable and accommodating, yet inserted pertinent information that helped with decision-making. Do yourself a favor, and choose this law firm to represent you! You will not be disappointed!”
J.H. | Medical Malpractice and Wrongful Death | FindLaw Review
“Thankfully, I was referred to the Olsman MacKenzie Peacock law firm when discussing my concerns with another attorney. They responded quickly and began the process of investigating our case of medical malpractice and negligence, which resulted in my young sister’s death. Emily Peacock took over the case, and was masterful, thorough, and calculated in building the case, leaving no stone unturned. She and her team kept me informed along each step of the road. This was a painful, difficult, and lengthy journey with many tears shed along the way, but Emily and the team were kind, thoughtful, compassionate, and understanding. They successfully achieved a positive outcome in our case, bringing justice to those responsible for my beautiful sister’s death.”
S.R. | Personal Injury Case | Google 5-Star Review
“Emily Peacock was absolutely phenomenal in her handling of my case. She thoroughly explained step by step exactly what was and would be happening. She made certain I understood every step. She was my rock through this hard journey. She fought for me when I felt like nobody was even listening to me. Her assistant Callie was so warm and compassionate in handling me as a person, not just a client. Emily is rockstar quality and I would recommend her to anyone in need of this kind of service.”
L.H. | Google 5-Star Review
“My attorney Emily Peacock went over and above to keep me informed about my case, explained everything to me as the process went along, and answered my calls and questions promptly. Her assistant Callie is also so helpful and kind. Thank you, Emily, for handling my case with knowledge, toughness, kindness, and compassion.”
J.M. | Google 5-Star Review
“I could not have asked for a better attorney. Jules Olsman handled my case with professionalism, confidence, and eagerness. I would 100 percent recommend any of the attorneys at this firm. Hopefully I will not need an attorney in the future, but if I do, I am calling Jules.”
TESTIMONIAL VIDEO
Injured in Michigan? Call OMP at 1-800-366-8653 for a Free Consultation
How Do Client Reviews Help Someone Choose the Right Michigan Medical Malpractice Attorney?
Medical malpractice litigation is a distinct discipline within personal injury law. The barriers to entry are significant. Under Michigan law, a plaintiff must file an affidavit of merit signed by a qualified medical professional before a case can proceed. Cases require expert witnesses, often multiple specialists, to establish that the standard of care was breached and that the breach caused the specific harm suffered. Defense teams hired by hospital systems and malpractice insurers are experienced and well-resourced.
Against that backdrop, reading reviews from real clients who have gone through a malpractice case with a particular firm provides information that credentials and awards cannot fully convey. The most instructive reviews address:
- Medical literacy. Did the firm demonstrate a working understanding of the patient’s condition, the applicable standard of care, and the nature of the alleged error?
- Tenacity against institutional defendants. How did the firm respond when a hospital system or physician denied responsibility and deployed its own defense team?
- Transparency about the process. Were the requirements of Michigan malpractice law, including the affidavit of merit and the notice of intent to sue, explained clearly at the outset?
- Emotional support alongside legal guidance. Did the attorneys and staff treat the client as a grieving patient or family member, not just a case number?
- Sustained communication. Given that malpractice cases in Michigan can take years to resolve, did the firm maintain consistent contact throughout the process?
At Olsman MacKenzie Peacock, we employ registered nurses on staff, including Nancy Studer and Jackie Liu, RN, BSN. Their clinical backgrounds assist attorneys in reviewing medical records, identifying where care fell short of accepted standards, and communicating the facts of complex medical situations in terms that are meaningful in the courtroom.
What Has Olsman MacKenzie Peacock Recovered for Medical Malpractice Clients in Michigan?
The following settlements and verdicts represent outcomes OMP has obtained for clients harmed by medical negligence in Michigan. Past results cannot guarantee future outcomes, as each case turns on its own facts, but these figures reflect the scope and variety of cases the firm has handled.
$8,000,000 – Settlement for victims of a physician at one of the largest cancer practices in Michigan who misdiagnosed patients with cancer, resulting in unnecessary and harmful treatment.
$4,400,000 – Jury verdict for a 59-year-old woman who suffered a stroke as a result of a medication error by her family physician.
$2,500,000- Settlement where a hospital delayed resuscitation of a premature infant despite parents pleading for assistance for the baby who was breathing and moving, resulting in severe anoxia.
$850,000 – Settlement for a 64-year-old man who died from a medication error when a rehabilitation center discharged him without anticoagulants specifically ordered by his physician’s assistant, causing a fatal blood clot.
$725,000 – Settlement for a 68-year-old man who was rendered quadriplegic and died after undergoing elective surgery.
$600,000 – Settlement for a 56-year-old man with coronary artery disease who died after an internal medicine physician prescribed Viagra and inhalers without first conducting a cardiac evaluation.
$525,000- Settlement for the failure to properly manage a patient’s psychiatric condition, resulting in suicide.
$380,000 – Settlement for a 63-year-old man who died because a physician failed to perform surgery for his bowel obstruction in a timely manner.
$275,000 – Settlement for an infant who suffered shoulder dystocia during a delivery performed by a resident.
$237,500 – Settlement for the family of a developmentally disabled woman who died after multiple physicians failed to timely diagnose and treat her bowel obstruction.
Past results are not a guarantee of future outcomes. Every case is different and results will depend on the specific facts and circumstances of each individual matter. The amounts above represent settlements and verdicts obtained on behalf of those specific clients.
What Should a Patient or Family Look for When Reading Medical Malpractice Lawyer Reviews?
Not every law firm that handles personal injury cases handles medical malpractice. And not every firm that handles medical malpractice has the infrastructure to take on complex cases involving major hospital systems, large physician practices, or multi-party surgical teams.
When reading reviews of Michigan medical malpractice attorneys, the most useful accounts tend to reflect:
- Whether the firm was willing to take the case in the first place, given that malpractice cases require a significant investment of time and resources before any recovery is possible
- Whether the attorney explained Michigan’s specific procedural requirements for malpractice cases, including the notice of intent period and the affidavit of merit requirement
- Whether the firm’s medical knowledge was evident throughout the case, including during depositions of the defendant physician and the firm’s own expert witnesses
- Whether the client felt the firm was genuinely prepared to take the case to trial if the defense refused to offer a fair settlement
- Whether the staff remained attentive and responsive throughout what is often a multi-year legal process
Generic praise is less informative than specific accounts of how an attorney handled a difficult deposition, navigated a dispute with the opposing expert, or kept a client grounded through a lengthy litigation. We encourage every client to share the details of their experience.
Why Is It Important to Hire an Attorney with Specific Medical Malpractice Experience in Michigan?
Michigan medical malpractice law contains procedural requirements that distinguish it from other personal injury claims. A prospective plaintiff must serve a notice of intent to file suit and wait 182 days before filing. The complaint must be accompanied by an affidavit of merit signed by a health professional in the same specialty as the defendant. Damage caps apply in certain categories. The statute of limitations is shorter than in many other states.
These requirements mean that early mistakes can be fatal to an otherwise strong case. An attorney who does not practice regularly in this area may overlook procedural deadlines, fail to identify the correct medical standard, or retain the wrong category of expert witness.
Our experienced medical malpractice attorneys have handled medical malpractice cases in Michigan for decades.
Reviews from past malpractice clients reflect the practical value of that depth of experience, particularly when facing the well-organized defense machinery that hospitals and malpractice insurers deploy in contested cases.
Why Do Patients and Families Choose Olsman MacKenzie Peacock for Michigan Medical Malpractice Cases?
The reviews featured on this page emphasize a few consistent themes. Clients describe a medical malpractice attorney team that was thorough in investigating the facts, honest about the timeline and difficulty of the process, and unwilling to walk away when hospitals or physicians denied wrongdoing.
Several reviews specifically highlight the experience of feeling unheard before contacting OMP, and of finally having someone in their corner who understood both the medicine and the law well enough to challenge the institutional defendants directly. That combination of clinical knowledge and courtroom preparedness distinguishes a true medical malpractice practice from a general personal injury firm.
OMP represents clients in medical malpractice cases arising from misdiagnosis and failure to diagnose, surgical errors, anesthesia complications, medication mistakes, birth injuries, fertility clinic negligence, and wrongful death. Our dedicated medical malpractice lawyers represent clients across Michigan from offices in Berkley, Lapeer, and Battle Creek. All cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning no attorney fees are owed unless a recovery is obtained.
Contact Olsman MacKenzie Peacock Today
Free Consultation | 1-800-366-8653
Berkley Office: 2684 West Eleven Mile, Berkley, Michigan 48072 | 248-591-2300
Lapeer Office: 350 North Court Street, Suite 209, Lapeer, Michigan 48446 | 810-667-9500
Battle Creek: 269-963-0375
The information on this page is provided for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Contacting OMP or submitting a contact form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results are not a guarantee of future outcomes.